Markets cycle. Downturns happen. Here's how to think about selling your mineral rights when commodity prices are down and what factors should guide your decision.
If you're considering selling your mineral rights during a period of lower commodity prices, you're not alone. Oil and gas markets are cyclical by nature. Prices rise, prices fall, and the cycle continues. Every mineral owner eventually faces the question of whether to sell during less favorable market conditions.
The truth is, there's no perfect time to sell. Waiting for "the top" of the market is nearly impossible to time correctly. What matters most is whether selling now meets your personal financial goals and circumstances.
Key insight: A downturn doesn't mean you can't sell or shouldn't sell. It means understanding current market reality and making decisions based on your situation, not speculation about the future.
Market downturns affect the mineral rights landscape in several ways. Understanding these dynamics helps you make informed decisions.
Lower commodity prices: Oil and gas fetch less per barrel/MCF
Reduced drilling activity: Operators slow or pause new wells
Some buyers exit: Speculative buyers may step back
Tighter valuations: Offers typically reflect current prices
More selective: Buyers focus on quality assets
Longer due diligence: Careful review of each property
Conservative projections: Less optimistic forecasts
Serious players remain: Established buyers stay active
Important: Your royalty income during a downturn is also affected by lower prices. The same barrel of oil that brought $80 might now bring $55. Your check shrinks even if production stays the same.
This is the central question many owners face. There are legitimate arguments on both sides.
Prices may recover and improve valuations
No immediate need for the capital
Strong ongoing production you enjoy
New development may be paused, not canceled
Capital needs don't wait for markets
Production declines regardless of prices
Recovery timing is unknown
Today's offer may still meet your needs
No one can tell you when prices will recover or how high they'll go. Professional traders, economists, and industry experts regularly get it wrong. Making decisions based on price predictions is speculation, not planning.
Your personal situation matters most. The right decision is the one that addresses your actual needs and goals, regardless of where we are in the market cycle.
Many mineral owners choose to sell even when market conditions aren't ideal. Here's why.
Capital requirements: Medical bills, debt payoff, or major purchases don't wait
Retirement funding: Need to convert assets to retirement income now
Business opportunities: Investment opportunities have their own timing
Declining wells: Production falling means less to sell later
Aging assets: Older wells may not benefit from recovery
No new drilling: Unlikely to see development boost soon
Estate planning: Simplification goals don't depend on oil prices
Health considerations: Time-sensitive situations
Family decisions: Divorce, inheritance, or relocation
Reinvestment: Deploy capital where it can grow
Risk reduction: Remove commodity price exposure
Certainty value: Known cash vs. unknown future
During challenging markets, buyers become more selective. Understanding what attracts buyers helps you assess your position.
Quality basins: Permian, Eagle Ford, and other core areas
Active production: Producing wells with documented history
Clear title: Clean ownership with no disputes
Good operators: Reputable companies working the wells
Market-based pricing: Sellers who understand current values
Documentation ready: Deeds, leases, and division orders available
Reasonable timeline: Willing to work through due diligence
Complete ownership: All interests consolidated
Good news: Quality assets in good locations continue to attract buyer interest in all market conditions. If your minerals are producing in an active basin, buyers are likely still interested.
Selling during a downturn doesn't mean accepting a bad deal. Here's how to approach the process thoughtfully.
Choose established buyers: Companies with track records and capital
Ask questions: Understand how they value your minerals
Compare approaches: Get perspectives from multiple buyers
Check references: Talk to others who have sold
Current market reality: Values reflect today's prices, not yesterday's
Focus on net proceeds: What matters is what you actually receive
Avoid comparisons: Past sales at higher prices aren't relevant benchmarks
Define fair: Does the offer achieve your financial goals?
Market downturns aren't all negative for sellers. Consider these factors:
Serious buyers remain: Those still buying are committed and well-capitalized
Less competition: Fewer sellers in the market can mean more attention to your property
Faster process: Buyers with capacity can move efficiently
Quality focus: Good assets stand out more clearly
Your goals matter: If an offer meets your needs, market timing is secondary
Capital deployment: Proceeds invested wisely may outperform waiting
Remember: The right time to sell is when it's right for you, not when market conditions are "perfect." Many successful sales happen during downturns because they meet real owner needs.
It depends on your personal circumstances and goals. Lower prices do affect valuations, but if you need capital, want to simplify your finances, or have declining production, selling during a downturn may still meet your needs. Focus on whether the offer achieves your financial goals rather than trying to time the market perfectly.
Yes, established buyers continue purchasing mineral rights in all market conditions. While some speculative buyers may exit during downturns, serious buyers with long-term investment horizons remain active. Quality assets in good basins continue to attract interest regardless of short-term price fluctuations.
There is no fixed percentage as it varies by property, location, and market conditions. Generally, valuations adjust based on current and projected commodity prices. However, strong producing assets in active basins typically hold their value better than marginal properties. The actual impact depends on your specific minerals.
No one can reliably predict when commodity markets will recover. Markets are influenced by global supply and demand, geopolitical events, economic conditions, and many other factors. Waiting for a recovery involves uncertainty about both timing and magnitude. Base your decision on your current needs rather than predictions about future markets.
Compare offers based on current market conditions, not past highs. Get multiple perspectives if possible. Work with established buyers who can explain their valuation methodology. A fair offer reflects what buyers are actually paying today, which is influenced by current commodity prices, production levels, and future development potential.
Market conditions change, but quality assets retain value. Get a straightforward evaluation of your mineral rights based on current market realities.
Get Your Free EvaluationOr call us at (404) 604-6364
Disclaimer: This information is provided for educational purposes only and does not constitute financial, legal, or tax advice. Mineral rights values and market conditions vary. Past market performance is not indicative of future results. Consult with qualified professionals for advice specific to your circumstances.